About persnickety’s

Hi, there!

I’m Erin, your local Plymouth-based cookier. I’ve always loved from-scratch, delicious food — especially sweets for celebrations! I started my cookie journey in December 2024 after binge-watching a holiday cookie competition and wondering, “Could I do that?” My first attempt was bumpy (literally), but I persevered and conquered royal icing. Now I enjoy the creativity of designing and decorating special cookies for clients, market events, holidays, and special occasions.


2026 EVENT SCHEDULE

February 21: February Craft Market @ Lincoln Event Center (Plymouth, IN) 10:00am-3:00pm

February 22: Bridal Expo @ Lincoln Event Center (Plymouth, IN) 11:00am-3:00pm

April 18: Nappanee Spring Market @ Claywood Event Center (Nappanee, IN) 8:30am-2:30pm

May 2: Mother Daughter Market @ Coppes Commons (Nappanee, IN) 11:00am-4:00pm